Skip to main content

AI vs An Automation for Brokers: What’s the Real Difference?

We take walkthrough the world of AI, helping brokers distinguish between simple rule-based automations and "True AI" capable of making intelligent assessments. We explore practical use cases such as fraud detection through OCR, AI agents for loan submission, and the use of LLMs for lender policy research. Ultimately, the episode serves as a roadmap for brokers to reduce their mental load and speed up service delivery by choosing the right intelligence for their specific business needs.

BrokerToolsKatey Shaw
February 20, 2026

Podcast Transcript

[00:00] Hi and welcome to Broker Tools, where we unpack the tools, systems, and strategies that help brokers optimize the way they work. I'm Katie, your host, and today we are discussing AI in your software. In this chat, we are joined by my digital companion, Gamma. Gamma is my favorite tool to use to generate presentations using AI. If you have been following along, you will notice that with this podcast, we have spoken to a lot of humans. We have spoken on the topics of uh lead generation, mindset, team development and systems. And the most common topic that we often discuss is AI and how brokers can use it in their business. As a CRM designer and AI automation specialist, I thought it would be good to do a walkthrough on what AI is or isn't so that when you go about assessing it and how to use it in your own business, you get a clear idea of what to expect from your software or services. So to begin, I want to be clear. I am not going through this whole

[01:02] presentation page by page. You can get this presentation from the website, navigate it yourself, and make a discussion with your team about what and how you may ultimately use AI in your business. For me, in what I'm trying to do here at Broker Tools is really help brokers generally speaking optimize the way they work. And AI generally speaking can be confusing especially when some people are using what we would call AI automations as part of the AI conversation when really it's not what we would call true AI. So to explain the difference within the industry of what would be considered true AI versus an automation using AI, it's the distinctive factor of whether or not this system, this tool, this process can make intelligent decisions, assessments, thoughts on your behalf and make suggestions for you. So often AI for example might be able to take a

[02:07] document, summarize it and come back with information for you. That is AI being able to read it, use some type of intelligence to decide this is the summary of that particular document. An AI automation or an automation using AI rather is a lot more rule-based. So you as the human have to set the definitions and the requirements for this system or process to use AI within it. For example, one of the things I commonly set up for a client is a way to make a presentation and most times it's generally speaking an automation. And by that what I mean is you'll have a pipeline. It'll have all the stages within it. Usually you will have had a discovery call. By the next stage it's create a presentation. And so when you move an opportunity or a deal into this stage called create a presentation, it has a trigger notification to do a set

[03:11] of tasks on your behalf. As an automation specialist, I usually set it up on behalf of my clients. I say if this stage is hit, do this next action. And usually that next action is get the template from one drive. That's your presentation document. It's it's a template. It's easy to do. Next, get the name best interest duty from the CRM and add it to this document. That's just a simple straight up automation. From here you can get the save the document, label the document, set the rules for how that document is labeled and named and then get the URL, the page link for that document and then take that link and put it back into your CRM. So that whole process is linked together. The next part of that same automation can be move it into the next stage to say review presentation. That's a whole automation.

[04:14] I've set the rules. I've set the triggers. I've set it in motion so that the system can make the decision to do it based on what I've said. That is just a straight up automation. Where it can be in a um automation with AI is using that same scenario where a stage has hit create a presentation. It still kind of goes through the same steps as the automation, but there's one extra step in that I can get the best interest duty for example from the CRM, feed it through chat GPT, claude, whatever tool you want to use and ask it to rewrite this best interest duty and then recraft it and then put it into the presentation. So, but that that is an AI inside an automation. Another way someone may use what we call an um AI in an automation is often what we call OCR. So OCRs um scan a document and read it and they

[05:19] do what we call pattern recognition. Most documents have a style to it. The way they are laid out is kind of like you know pre-formatted. So often for example driver's license a driver's license number usually sits in the same spot all the time. That is it you know using I guess some AI intelligence to scan and predictively say hey this is where a driver's license number is. The part that is the automation is extract that number from this place that we've told you to find it and put it for example in my CRM. That way um when you need to use it to say do an Equifax soft hit you can take that and validate that that's a valid driver's license. That's again sets of rules using an AI automative process to do it because the

[06:24] system has been able to use AI to distinguish that this document is a driver's license. It's been able to say this is where the driver's license is. And then the automation says these are the rules I want you to follow next. Using that same process, we can then start doing some intelligent stuff. And most you'll find with most CRM or most systems that are currently in the market for you as a broker, they're not this whole sophisticated workflow that I've got here. Most of them are getting there. I think it's FE and if you're an enterprise solution, then um data exchange with Docs AI can do this whole process for you. I know that lend is probably on the way to having this type of thing in place, but it's this part where you can scan a document, distinguish what it is, pull out particular fields, redact data. So, for example, you don't want to have

[07:26] tax file numbers, you can redact that information out of that document. you can actually read and scan the document to see if that document has any fraud detection capabilities within it. So what's that fraud detection? It's like you're noticing that that logo on that document um say a pay slip is it's like it looks like it's copied and paste there like there's these just like a little kind of frame around the logo that normally wouldn't be there if it was a genuine document. And it can then you know flag those documents and say hey this document looks you know 56% authentic or whatever the ratio is based on the different markers that have been identified as fraudulent. And then again you can have this all feed fed back into your CRM to to again make your own determination whether or not this document is genuine or you have to redo that whole document when you are looking for I guess AI

[08:29] within your software. Right now I'm just talking about process workflows in simple AI. The other way intelligent AI can work which I didn't really put in this presentation is lender policy. You know, I was talking to um Jack just a moment ago and the way he does it is he runs his scenario with I think chat GPT or what was it? Grock. Actually, I think it's Grock. And he puts in the whole scenario inside of there and he goes, "This is what I'm looking for. Please recommend me some lenders." And boom, out comes an outcome. That's, you know, what we call intelligent AI, optimizing the way you work so that you can decide what to do next. Automations obviously can help feed that information, but you don't have to use automations everywhere. I'm just trying to help I guess help you categorize the difference between true AI and automation and an automation using AI because when it comes to I guess other areas of your business. So we've really covered right

[09:31] now your workflow automation and how to streamline that using AI and there are many softwares out there. I think probably FE would be the closest to having the most AI enablement within their software compared to others. And when you have a look at it, you have to decide for yourself, what kind of intelligence do I need to get started. I've looked at things like the HubSpot system and they've got a really great, you know, way of having calls come through their CRM system and you can do a call summary and you can log it against a opportunity or a deal. And by doing that, it means that you're building out this source of truth, this back data, I guess, of information that should you meet up with this client 3 years from now because they're ready to buy another investment property, you've got that intelligence, you've got that history, and then you can do an inquiry and say, you know, based on the last purchase, you know, what has happened?

[10:36] and it can come back and give you a conversation as to what happened, what would be a great opportunity for them and and ultimately that's how you can start to really use the intelligent side of AI within your business. Where am I? Oh, that's right. Sorry. Trying to think of the best way to address AI chat, generative AI, and AI agents. I'm going to go talk about AI agents first and then I'll talk about the other two because I feel like AI chat and generative AI is more closely aligned to what we I would call the marketing side of your business rather than the automations and the systems and the management flow. Whereas AI agents can help you with the business operational side and management flow. So when you think about an agent, what it does is it takes your job description or rules for them as a person to execute on this particular role. I find that a software

[11:42] like financable, which is really just a loan origination software for people in the finance and commercial industry, they've they kind of demonstrate how they use this really well. And that is it's almost a way of doing copy and paste for your loan submission. So it reads into your CRM the the particular fields that you have assigned to this job for your AI agent to grab the data from and submit over in your lenders portal. It can log into the portal for you. It can take that information and it can copy and paste it in there for you. It kind of just really reduces all of that type of physical activity task that an admin person would do and it does it quite fast and in in no time at all. AI agents especially in this particular industry of mortgage broking, commercial asset finance always need a human in the loop to verify and check that the work

[12:44] is done correctly. And so ultimately agents act like task workers within your business. you it you give it a set of rules but it can intelligently decide what to do within your business and on your behalf and it usually will can do that within your CRM as well. Now I'm trying to think of how best to talk about AI chats and generative AI. What I have found works with most of the people that I tend to consult to is I like building out knowledge bases in their website. So these are like frequently asked questions. these uh common kinds of pieces of data that that particular industry or niche would need to know about to get their answers. So for example, I have a client who does a lot of low do you know management and so we built out a whole knowledge base on low docks the questions that someone would ask on a low doc and and put that into their website. So, it's not only just good SEO pieces of content, but when we add the chatbot in there, if someone

[13:50] goes, I'm looking to understand a little bit more about loan do low do sorry, it can come out and pull out that that particular data. There are tools that you can use such as um voice flow or bot press. Um even uh go high level has a really good chatbot in there that can do some of these types of things. You can choose your own and have this chatbot you know generate answers based on your website intelligence. Generative AI on the other hand is uh taking your written text and transforming it into something else. So we kind of gave an example earlier with you know the best interest in having that you know fed through and recrafted into another piece of text or content that is also generative AI but it also is a a text to image or a text to video type tool. So you can write these for

[14:53] example inside of Nana Banana which is my favorite way to use Google AI imaging. And just as an FYI, make sure you if you are going to use Nano Banana that you go through the Google Lab links uh because there is a site out there called Nano Banana and it makes you pay and it's not the genuine one. So just make sure you double check the links and that it is from Google. Anyway, coming back to what it does is you can describe the image you want. I often use it for my blog post images. I'll say this is the topic. This is what we're talking about. Please create a blog post image and boom a picture comes up. I then either give it feedback, have it readjusted and then you know hopefully it fixes it correctly and then you can download it and add it to your website. That is generative AI. How so ultimately I've obviously covered a quite a few areas of AI how AI could be with used within your business. the key difference between what we would call an automative

[15:58] AI versus an AI intelligence, but I know that there are a lot of questions out there by brokers about AI and how best to use it in their business. And so I would love to hear from you and let me know so I can create better videos cuz I've just given you a general overview of the difference between AI in your software, AI in your business, and how to use it as a workflow management system. But there are so many ways I can take it and I just want to make sure I'm giving you the right information at the right time because obviously it's overwhelming. But the whole goal of any AI in your system should be three key things. And that is does it reduce your mental load? Does it speed up your processes in service and delivery? And can it save you time and energy managing any of your compliance duties? If it fits all those requirements, then go ahead, use it. If you get confused or not sure what you should do next, then reach out. Um, because I love talking

[17:02] AI. I love simplifying AI. I also enjoy making sure that people don't get misled by someone using what I call fake AI analogies and saying that their software is AI when really I think of it more like a AI automation which is not true AI anyway that's just me having a little winge but again I can live and breathe all of this stuff AI generally speaking if I was to say something clearly for how you should use it is is think about your day and what would make it easier, better, and faster to move through it. If it can do that for you, then do that. If you don't know where to start, reach out. Thank you.

Podcast with our Editor, Katey on AI & Automation

In this episode, learn how Finance Brokers can distinguish between "true AI" and simple automation to avoid the hype and find real efficiency. As a CRM designer and AI automation specialist, shares strategies to categorise AI tools, build intelligent document workflows, and deploy AI agents that deliver a reduced mental load and faster service delivery in the Finance sector.

2. Episode Links

▶️ WATCH THE FULL PODCAST HERE: https://youtu.be/_3m4ewJ_n3c

🌐 Book a Chat HERE: https://www.brokertools.com.au/workflow-optimisation

3. The Core Problem with AI

The term "AI" is being used as a catch-all marketing buzzword, leaving you confused about what tools actually provide value versus what is just a simple set of rules. This often lacks:

  • Clarity on Definitions: The inability to distinguish between a rule-based "if-this-then-that" automation and a system that makes intelligent assessments.
  • Effective Document Management: Spending hours manually scanning, redacting, and data-entering driver's licenses and pay slips.
  • A Cohesive Tech Roadmap: Feeling overwhelmed by "feature fatigue" and not knowing which AI tools actually impact the bottom line.

Without these foundations, you will hit ceilings and feel drained by the mental load of repetitive administrative tasks.

4. The Big Shift: The "Intelligent Decision" Framework

Our key philosophy at Broker Tools is simple but transformative:

"The distinctive factor of true AI is whether or not the system can make intelligent decisions, assessments, and suggestions on your behalf—not just follow a set of pre-defined rules."

Through this approach, we teach you how to:

  • Audit Software Claims: Determine if a tool is "True AI" (intelligent summaries) or "AI Automation" (rule-based triggers).
  • Deploy Human-in-the-Loop Agents: Use AI agents as "task workers" that handle physical data entry into lender portals while maintaining human oversight.
  • Leverage Knowledge Bases: Turn frequently asked questions into searchable website intelligence for clients.
  • Automate Compliance: Use OCR (Optical Character Recognition) to instantly redact tax file numbers and detect potential document fraud.

5. Key Takeaways for Brokers

  • Intelligence is key marker of True AI: If a system can read a complex document and return a concise, intelligent summary, you are dealing with true AI.
  • The "Stage Trigger" Automation: Moving a deal to "Create Presentation" in your CRM can trigger an automation to grab a OneDrive template and auto-fill client names without "intelligence."
  • Fraud Detection via OCR: Advanced AI can now scan pay slips to detect "frames" around logos or other markers that suggest a document has been doctored.
  • Lender Policy via LLMs: You might now start using tools like Grok or ChatGPT to run complex scenarios and receive instant lender recommendations.
  • The Three-Pronged AI Test: Only adopt AI if it reduces mental load, speeds up process/delivery, or saves time on compliance.

6. The Connection: Strategy to Result

You don’t optimise your workday through buying more software alone — they grow through categorising and streamlining their management flow. When these foundations are in place:

  • Reduced Mental Load: You no longer have to remember the "next step" because the system prompts or executes it for you.
  • Faster Turnaround: Loan submissions that used to take an hour of copy-pasting are handled in minutes by AI agents.
  • Data Integrity: Intelligent history logs in your CRM (like HubSpot call summaries) ensure you have a "source of truth" when a client returns 3 years later.

7. Practical Next Steps

  • Step 2: Define: Identify repetitive tasks (e.g., redacting TFNs) that could be handled by an automation or AI.
  • Step 3: Document: Build out a simple FAQ "Knowledge Base" on your niche (like Low Doc loans) to feed a website chatbot.
  • Step 4: Tooling: Explore AI-enabled platforms like Effi or Financeable that offer native AI agent capabilities.
  • Step 5: Optimization: Use Nano Banana (Google Lab version) to generate unique, on-brand images for your marketing content.

8. Closing & Resource Recommendation

Listen To The Full Episode with Katey as she shows brokers how to navigate the AI landscape — by building a system that prioritises intelligence over hype. If you’ve ever felt misled by "fake AI" marketing, this conversation is a must-listen.

⚠️ Disclaimer: This content is for educational and research purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or business advice. Always verify AI-generated data (Human-in-the-Loop) before submitting any loan documents or legal advice.

Make growth feel automatedwith Broker Tools workflows.

Browse the directory and compare software or services made for the Mortgage, Asset or Commercial broker in Australia. Need help to uncover the ideal tech stack for your workflow and growth goals?  Work with us.